Marija LJAKOSKA,
Mirjanka MADJEVIKJ,
Biljana APOSTOLOVSKA TOSHEVSKA
Ss. Cyril and Methodius University
Faculty of Natural Sciences and Mathematics,
Institute of Geography,
Skopje, N. Macedonia
e-mail: marija.ljakoska@pmf.ukim.mk
UDC:
DOI:
ABSTRACT
This paper examines several interrelated, recurring methodological problems that limit the comparability of demographic data in North Macedonia and the wider post-Yugoslav Balkan region: changes in census methodology and in the definition of the resident population; repeated administrative-territorial reorganization of municipalities; the prolonged, multi-decade absence of census enumeration, illustrated by North Macedonia’s own nineteen-year gap between the 2002 and 2021 censuses; the restricted temporal and spatial resolution of settlement-level data; and instability in the recording of ethnic structure, mother tongue and religion. These problems are situated within the Modifiable Areal Unit Problem and successive United Nations vital-statistics standards, illustrated with evidence from the municipality of Kichevo, and compared with parallel cases from Serbia, Croatia, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Romania and Czechia. The paper concludes by considering the growing role of alternative and complementary data sources and outlines a research practice better suited to longitudinal and territorially disaggregated demographic analysis in North Macedonia.
Keywords: statistical data, census comparability, territorial-administrative reorganization, ethnic structure, migration statistics, Modifiable Areal Unit Problem
REFERENCES
- Antoine, P., & Rakotonarivo, A. (2012). Biographical surveys. In Social Differentiation and Inequalities: Methodological and Cross-cutting Approaches to Questions of Gender and Ethnicity. Tam Đảo Summer School Week, July 2011. Paris: AFD/CEPED.
- Apostolovska Toshevska, B., & Madjevikj, M. (2008). Третманот на социоекономските податоци во наставата по географија [The treatment of socioeconomic data in geography teaching]. Geographical Reviews, 41–42, 167–174.
- Bakić, D., & Radić, N. (2017). Demografski potencijali i ograničenja kao činilac u prostornom planiranju. Zbornik radova mladih istraživača, Palić-Subotica.
- Bartha, G., & Kocsis, S. (2011). Standardization of geographic data: The European INSPIRE directive. European Journal of Geography, 2(2), 79–89.
- Dimitrov, N. (2005). Демографски контрасти на населението во Република Македонија според националност, мајчин јазик и вероисповед (Попис 1994–2002). Зборник од Третиот конгрес на географите од Република Македонија, 192–205.
- Djurdjev, B. S., Arsenović, D., & Dragin, A. (2010). Contemporary problems in studying population of Vojvodina Province. Acta geographica Slovenica, 50(1), 115–129.
- Drandić, A. (2013). Demografska analiza podataka matičnih knjiga krštenih i vjenčanih župe Svetvinčenat (1875.–1900.). Vjesnik istarskog arhiva, 20, 113–141.
- Drašković, D., & Nikitović, V. (2022). Podacima do boljeg razumevanja procesa depopulacije. Stanovništvo.
- Eklund, L., Romankiewicz, C., Brandt, M., Doevenspeck, M., & Samimi, C. (2016). Data and methods in the environment-migration nexus: A scale perspective. DIE ERDE, 147(2), 139–152.
- Eurostat / Council of Europe (n.d.). Demographic Statistics: A Review of Definitions and Methods of Collection in 44 European Countries.
- Ferry, M., & Vironen, H. (2010). Dealing with Demographic Change: Regional Policy Responses. European Policy Research Paper No. 72.
- Finney, N. (2020). Population geography I: Epistemological opportunities of mixed methods. Progress in Human Geography.
- Government of the Republic of Macedonia, Ministry of Labour and Social Policy (2008). Strategy for Demographic Development of the Republic of Macedonia 2008–2015.
- Government of the Republic of Macedonia, Ministry of Labour and Social Policy (2015). Strategy for Demographic Policies of the Republic of Macedonia 2015–2024.
- Iliev, D. (2018). Interregional inequalities at NUTS level 3 in Macedonia. AUC Geographica, 53(2).
- Jovanović, J., & Živković, D. (2008). Картографска уникфикација демографских показатеља [Cartographic unification of demographic indicators]. Демографија, V.
- Kiss, T. (2013). Analysis of Existing Migratory Data Production Systems and Major Data Sources in Romania. SEEMIG Country Report. Romanian Institute for Research on National Minorities.
- Knežević, A. (2011). Методолошки проблеми етностатистичке евиденције и етнодемографских проучавања становништва Србије. Демографија, VIII, 129–144.
- Knežević, A. (2014). Методолошки проблеми демографске анализе: усаглашавање података пописне и виталне статистике са административно-територијалним променама (пример Источне Србије). Демографија, XI, 53–66.
- Knežević, A. (2022). The methodological issues of census ethnostatistics in the light of contemporary migration trends in Serbia. Migracijske i etničke teme, 38(2), 125–148.
- Knežević, A., & Radić, N. (2016). Categorization of ethnic identity in population censuses: Between theoretical understandings and statistical practice. Stanovništvo, 54(2), 59–81.
- Knežević, A., & Vojković, G. (2015). Spatial extent in demographic research: Approach and problems. Bulletin of the Serbian Geographical Society, XCVI(2).
- Krajić, A. (2013). Demographic features and functional classification of settlements of Srem. Researches Reviews of the Department of Geography, Tourism and Hotel Management, 42.
- Ljakoska, M. (2016). The ethnic structure of the population in the municipality of Kichevo and its territorial distribution. Geographical Reviews, 49, 27–38.
- Ljakoska, M., & Iliev, D. (2013). Depopulation of the village settlements in the former municipalities Vraneshtica and Drugovo. Proceedings of the International Scientific Symposium “Hilly Mountain Areas,” Ohrid, 177–183.
- Ljakoska, M., & Madjevikj, M. (2017). The rural exodus in the municipality of Kichevo. Geographical Reviews, 50, 83–95.
- Ljakoska, M., Madjevikj, M., Apostolovska Toshevska, B., & Ninevska, H. (2024). Typology of municipalities by its population size – the case of North Macedonia. Geographical Reviews.
- Lukić Tanović, M., & Marinković, D. (2024). Попис становништва у Босни и Херцеговини: Између политичких интереса и неповољних демографских процеса. Зборник Матице српске за друштвене науке, LXXV(189), 53–67.
- Madjevikj, M., & Apostolovska Toshevska, B. (2013). Types of indicators in socioeconomic geography. Annual of the Institute of Geography, 39/40, 102–132.
- Madjevikj, M., & Ljakoska, M. (2018). Population data sources on the web and their importance. Geographical Reviews, 51.
- Marinković, D. (2019). Demografski razvoj i sprovođenje mjera populacione politike u Republici Srpskoj.
- Mutabdžija, G. (2018). Concept and importance of statistical regions on the example of Bosnia and Herzegovina. Journal of the Geographical Institute “Jovan Cvijić” SASA, 68(2).
- Nejašmić, I. (2011). Primijenjena istraživanja u demogeografiji. Hrvatski geografski glasnik, 73(1), 29–37.
- Nikolić, T. (2024). Izvori podataka o unutrašnjim migracijama u Srbiji sa aspekta prostornog planiranja. Demografija, 21, 79–94.
- Office for National Statistics (2015). Divorce Statistics: Metadata. London: ONS.
- Openshaw, S. (1984). The Modifiable Areal Unit Problem. CATMOG 38. Norwich: Geo Books.
- Openshaw, S., & Taylor, P. J. (1979). A million or so correlation coefficients: three experiments on the modifiable areal unit problem. In Statistical Applications in the Spatial Sciences.
- Popović, V. (2020). Significance of functional organization of settlements for development of primary rural settlements in the City of Zaječar. Researches Reviews of the Department of Geography, Tourism and Hotel Management, 49-1.
- Radovanović, S. (1996). Могућности коришћења статистичке грађе за анализу етнографских и етнодемографских процеса. Zbornik radova Geografski institut “Jovan Cvijić” SANU, 46, 265–273.
- Ratkaj, I. (2007). Квантитативни показатељи стамбене сегрегације. Зборник радова Географског факултета Универзитета у Београду, LV.
- Republički zavod za statistiku Srbije (RZS) (2022). O popisu 2022: Najčešća pitanja o popisu. Beograd: RZS. https://popis2022.stat.gov.rs/sr-cyrl/2-opopisu-2021/
- Schatz, E. (2012). Rationale and procedures for nesting semistructured interviews in surveys or censuses. Population Studies, 66(2), 183–195.
- Sotiroski, K., & Hristoski, I. (2014). Statistical performances of population migration in the Republic of Macedonia at the beginning of the 21st century. Migracijske i etničke teme, 30(1), 33–65.
- Spasenović, S., & Devedžić, M. (2012). Fertilitet stanovništva Beograda u kontekstu teorije druge demografske tranzicije. Zbornik Matice srpske za društvene nauke.
- State Statistical Office of the Republic of Macedonia (SSO) (2002). Census of Population, Households and Dwellings in the Republic of Macedonia, 2002 — Final Data, Book I. Skopje: State Statistical Office.
- State Statistical Office of the Republic of North Macedonia (SSO) (2022). Total Resident Population, Households and Dwellings in the Republic of North Macedonia, Census 2021. Skopje: State Statistical Office.
- State Statistical Office of the Republic of North Macedonia (SSO) (n.d.). MakStat Database. https://makstat.stat.gov.mk/PXWeb/pxweb/mk/MakStat/
- Trnavčević, N., & Knežević, A. (2023). The demographic approach to the quality of official ethnicity data in Serbia – a research proposal. Stanovništvo, 61(1), 17–33.
- UNFPA (n.d.). Methodological Guidelines for the Gender Analysis of National Population and Housing Census Data, Part Two.
- United Nations, Statistical Office (1953). Principles for a Vital Statistics System. Statistical Papers, Series M, No. 19. New York: United Nations.
- United Nations, Statistical Office (1973). Principles and Recommendations for a Vital Statistics System, Revision 1. Statistical Papers, Series M, No. 19, Rev. 1. New York: United Nations.
- United Nations, Statistics Division (1999/2001). Principles and Recommendations for a Vital Statistics System, Revision 2. Statistical Papers, Series M, No. 19, Rev. 2. New York: United Nations.
- United Nations, Department of Economic and Social Affairs, Population Division (2005).
World Population Prospects: The 2004 Revision, Volume III: Analytical Report. New York: United Nations. - Vachuška, J., & Kurkin, R. (2022). The first results for the population characteristics of the 2021 Census in Czechia. Demografie, 64(4), 335–352.
- Vidicki, V., & Stojšin, S. (2021). Prevazilaženje metodološkog dogmatizma u društvenim istraživanjima: triangulacija, multimetod i kombinovani metodi. Sociologija, LXIII(1).
- Vidicki, V. D., & Stojšin, S. S. (2023). Problem uzorka u kombinovanom pristupu istraživanju. Годишњак Филозофског факултета у Новом Саду, XLVIII(1–2).
- Voss, P. R. (2004). Demography as a Spatial Social Science. Applied Population Laboratory, University of Wisconsin-Madison.
- WHO (2017). WHO methods and data sources for country-level causes of death 2000–2015. Geneva: Department of Information, Evidence and Research, World Health Organization.